Deciding how to categorize this post was a bit difficult since it could go either under 'Books', or 'Television and Movies'......I chose the latter since it was the movie media that sparked this random rambling!
Anyone who has browsed through this blog, or who knows me at all will remember that I'm not a movie goer, typically. Don't ask me if I've 'seen' stuff. Because I haven't, generally. I don't care for the theatre.....it's too hot, the seats are uncomfortable, and the habits of the other movie goers are often annoying. Who knows, it may have something to do with being taken to a show as a small child and having two obnoxious little boys behind me spend the entire duration of the film (whatever the hell it was) throwing buttered popcorn into my hair.
Now and then Dave and I will rent movies and watch them in the comfort of our own home, with the pause button there and ready for pee and snack breaks. Or someone will lend us a film, and such was the case recently when my best friend lent me 'The Lion, The Witch and the Wardrobe', and 'Prince Caspian'. I'm going to say right here that I've been actively avoiding these pictures, for a few different reasons.....never mind what all of them are.....the main two being that I tend to avoid anything Disney affiliated, and that I didn't see how these Narnia books by CS Lewis could possibly translate effectively into film. The efforts I'd seen thus far on television did not impress.
You see, the Narnia books hold a rare distinction of the sacred for me, irrevocably bound up with childhood memories of my mother reading the series to my sister and myself, of this incredible world of faith and fantasy unfolding page by page. I remember in particular, one night after the nightly story-time had ended and I was lying in the darkness trying to go to sleep, my mind filled with images of fauns and centaurs and Aslan the lion......my mom came back to my room and put her head around the door. 'Do you get what's happening in the story?' She whispered almost conspiratorially. 'It's a parallel, Aslan is supposed to be Christ, he was killed on the stone table just like Christ was supposed to have died on the cross for the sins of mankind, and then was resurrected.' My parents were not affiliated with any particular known faith system and neither am I, our family were not 'churchy' in any way, shape or form. But still this parallel fascinated her. I do not classify myself as a Christian, yet these Christian allegorical Narnia stories still have the power to instill in me a sense of the sacred.
But having finally given in and watched the movies, I was in fact impressed, in spite of myself. In particular, 'The Lion, The Witch and the Wardrobe' was very, very good, keeping closely to the original story with only very minor changes. It's amazing what they can do with special effects these days, and the various creatures with which these stories are populated actually look pretty amazing on film. And the four Pevensie children who feature in the first and second books (and movies) are extremely well cast. It's a bit weird but they are exactly how I always imagined them to look and act, which gives me a strange feeling, like coming face-to-face with old friends after many years apart. And Aslan the lion almost makes me want to fall on my knees in awe, as the characters in the film do when he appears.
I was a bit less enamoured of 'Prince Caspian'. I found that the story was changed around a bit too much to suit me, although it stayed the same in it's very basic premise. Again, the portrayal of the four Pevensie children was excellent, with the same four actors as in the first film, but just older enough to be convincing and in keeping with the passage of one year that is supposed to have occurred between their Narnian visits. (At least, by their perspective.....in Narnia of course a thousand years has passed.) I wasn't as impressed with Caspian; although I couldn't deny that he was a handsome young thing he wasn't at all how I imagined him, nor were any of the Telmarine race. I thought the hint of a love interest between Susan and Caspian (which did not occur in the book) was a bit silly and it added nothing whatsoever to the story to my mind. I remarked on a few occasions to Dave as we watched that if I hadn't read the book I would have no clue at all as to what was going on. It didn't seem to make it perfectly clear in the beginning what was happening in Narnia at the time, which kind of resulted in the whole movie being a bit disjointed. Never mind.....it had it's redeeming qualities in the form of Aslan and the other beings of Narnia being amazingly brought to life. I imagine it's not easy to make a centaur look convincing, but they seem to pull it off.
Now I hear that the movie adaptation of the third book in the series of seven, 'The Voyage of the Dawn Treader' is out in theatres. In this story, Lucy and Edmund Pevensie and their cousin Eustace arrive in Narnia and join Caspian on a sea voyage to the eastern edge of the world. This is the last book that includes any of the Pevensie children until they all reunite at the very end of the series. Well, almost all of them.....in the books, Susan is the only one who is not present at that ending/beginning place, a fact that puzzles and bothers me now as much as it did when I was a child. I'm not the only one who doesn't understand the exclusion of Susan at the end. In the final Narnia book, 'The Last Battle', it's explained that Susan is no longer 'a friend of Narnia' and Lucy remarks that her older sister has forgotten about Narnia in favour of parties and make-up and playing at being 'grown-up'. Is this a lesson that CS Lewis was trying to interject, that if you lose the faith you will not find salvation? And will the detail of the loss of Susan make it into the movie version of The Last Battle?
I've read that since the Prince Caspian movie did not do as well as expected at the box office, Disney has dropped the project (typical of them, I guess the more than 1 billion grossed by the first two films wasn't enough to keep them interested) and that 20th Century Fox has taken over as financial backer and distributor. So when Dawn Treader comes out on Blu-ray I'll be renting, and watching.